Jump to content

"); //]]>
");

SurfCanister web protection software - free or not free?




  • Please log in to reply
8 replies to this topic

#1

marko

marko

    Platinum Poster!

  • Administrators
  • 12,287 posts
    ***UPDATE - 28/06/2012***
    Since we published this matter, the developer of SurfCanister contacted us and acknowledged the wording could be seen as confusing and has since updated their website and the wording which has went from "Download FREE Beta" to "Download Trial Beta". Thanks to the team at SurfCanister for making those changes and being responsible enough to become involved in the discussion - job done :)
    ============================================================

    Despite various claims from this developers website of this product being "free", it would seem in fact that it's no more than a trial version.

    Note the homepage claims (surfcanister.com) of "Download FREE Beta" ....

    24-06-2012 14-33-53.png

    .... or hit the download button and be told further "You could download FREE beta version of SurfCanister here" .....

    24-06-2012 14-34-17.png

    but then read a little further down that page and you'll see ....

    Quote

    Go to the Home Page. Enter your email id in 'Register New User' textbox.
    Then Click on Register button.
    Your account credentials and SurfCanister trial license key will be sent to registered email account
    Enter your username and password to login to your account.
    User can find product trial license key and download setup in it's ?My Profile? menu.
    User could also find the product trial license key at registered email account.

    This has all the hallmarks of foreign development, note the line "You could download FREE beta version of SurfCanister here", instead of better grammar such as "You can download the FREE beta version". But say it as you like, either it's free or it's not, but their own claims on their own website say it is, then contradict the claim by asking for a registration in return for a "trial" license key!.
    Please post your queries, requests and enquiries in the forums - do not PM me directly as I cannot answer everyone individually - your post stands a much better chance of receiving multiple replies from other members too on the forums.

    Please remember that we have people from many different timezones on the site and if your post requires a reply it could take longer at some at some points because of this.

    Forums
    New Freeware on the site
    Updated Freeware on the site
    RSS Subscribe
    Report bad freeware here

    #2

    Claw

    Claw

      Platinum Poster!

    • Advanced Member
    • 1,354 posts
      A classic form of underhanded deception at work. Nice catch marko. :good:

      #3

      James (Jim) Hillier

      James (Jim) Hillier

        Platinum Poster!

      • Super Mod
      • 1,216 posts
        My guess would be that this is a new startup. I believe what they are saying, rather clumsily, is that you can download and use the Beta version for free but only up until it is replaced by a final (commercial) release. Sort of a free Beta testing period.

        This is becoming a pretty common practice these days, some developers even offer free licenses for the final release to those testers who offer the most useful feedback.

        So yes, it definitely fits into the 'trial' model. Unfortunately, these people have not explained the concept very well at all, and what they have said is most misleading.
        Jim Hillier - Managing editor Daves Computer Tips.com

        #4

        surfcanister2011

        surfcanister2011

          New Poster!

        • Members
        • 2 posts
          Hello Sir\Madam


          According to your Question, "either it's free or it's not?" We arestartup and we are in our beta phase. Hence for now we make our software freeware.When we launch our commercial version, then we make our software availablefor "Trial version".


          Regards
          Surfcanister Team

          #5

          marko

          marko

            Platinum Poster!

          • Administrators
          • 12,287 posts
            The issue here is your statements are contradictory - you also submit software to freeware sites under the pretence of freeware, it isn't freeware, it's trialware. Thousands of developers do this and it causes responsible download sites like mine a massive headache trying to figure out which is real freeware and which is demo, trialware, shareware, etc. The man hours I spend trying to figure this nonsense out could be better spent elsewhere. Thanks for taking the time to respond here, but it would be better if developers stop submitting trialware as freeware in the first place, then you (or I) wouldn't be in this position in the first place.
            Please post your queries, requests and enquiries in the forums - do not PM me directly as I cannot answer everyone individually - your post stands a much better chance of receiving multiple replies from other members too on the forums.

            Please remember that we have people from many different timezones on the site and if your post requires a reply it could take longer at some at some points because of this.

            Forums
            New Freeware on the site
            Updated Freeware on the site
            RSS Subscribe
            Report bad freeware here

            #6

            James (Jim) Hillier

            James (Jim) Hillier

              Platinum Poster!

            • Super Mod
            • 1,216 posts

              View Postsurfcanister2011, on 25 June 2012 - 05:58 AM, said:

              Hello Sir\Madam

              According to your Question, "either it's free or it's not?" We arestartup and we are in our beta phase. Hence for now we make our software freeware.When we launch our commercial version, then we make our software availablefor "Trial version".

              Regards
              Surfcanister Team

              You must surely understand that "freeware" means free FOREVER - not just for a short period of time, until a certain event takes place.

              The problem I have is that you do NOT make this situation completely clear. Why didn't you include the same information (as in your comment here) on your product page somewhere? By not being up front and entirely transparent, it gives the distinct impression that you are deliberately trying to mislead.

              If the software is only available for free up until such times as the final commercial version is released, then why haven't you included that information on your site?
              Jim Hillier - Managing editor Daves Computer Tips.com

              #7

              surfcanister2011

              surfcanister2011

                New Poster!

              • Members
              • 2 posts
                Sorry for the inconvenience caused.

                We will make it a trialware while submitting here onward. We were thinking to give it FREE to school and college students so this confusion but we have not decided yet.

                Thanks,
                SurfCanister Team.

                #8

                marko

                marko

                  Platinum Poster!

                • Administrators
                • 12,287 posts
                  I've included an update on the first post of this thread to show that the team at SurfCanister have since amended their wording on the website to show the word "trial" in place of the word "free" which, for me, shows great responsiveness from the developers and is testament to our aim :)
                  Thanks to all concerned
                  Marko
                  Please post your queries, requests and enquiries in the forums - do not PM me directly as I cannot answer everyone individually - your post stands a much better chance of receiving multiple replies from other members too on the forums.

                  Please remember that we have people from many different timezones on the site and if your post requires a reply it could take longer at some at some points because of this.

                  Forums
                  New Freeware on the site
                  Updated Freeware on the site
                  RSS Subscribe
                  Report bad freeware here

                  #9

                  James (Jim) Hillier

                  James (Jim) Hillier

                    Platinum Poster!

                  • Super Mod
                  • 1,216 posts
                    Yep, hats off to the SurfCanister team. And to you also Marko.
                    Jim Hillier - Managing editor Daves Computer Tips.com




                    Similar Topics




                    0 user(s) are reading this topic

                    0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users